Banning Refugees from Australia: Not Targeting Those Preying on the Vulnerable: Just Preying on the Vulnerable – Oxford Human Rights Hub Blog

Extract from an article by William Phillips, 14th December 2016

As previously discussed on this blog … since 2001, Australia has made concerted efforts to intercept all ‘unauthorised maritime arrivals’ (this being the choice phrasing for asylum seekers used in the Migration Act 1958(Cth)) and transport them to detention centres outside of the Australian migration zone or in other states. What theMigration Legislation Amendment (Regional Processing Cohort) Bill 2016 (Cth) would do is amend the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) to prevent anyone intercepted in the course of these operations since 19 July 2013 from obtaining any kind of visa, including a tourist or business visa.

As Alex Reilly notes … , this means that, not only will thousands of asylum seekers be denied resettlement in Australia, but they will also be unable ever to visit or meet their family members or friends who have successfully been resettled in Australia. This class will include those asylum seekers currently held in offshore detention centres, those who have since been sent to other countries, and future intercepted arrivals. The only respite from this harsh measure will be given to children, who will not be captured by the proposed law’s draconian provisions, and any person the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection deigns – based on an assessment of the public interest – shouldn’t be subject to the ban.

It might be asked, what exactly would this new law achieve? Australia already has the legislative mechanisms in place to prevent asylum seekers from entering its territory and for processing them offshore. The constitutionality of these structures has been upheld in cases like Plaintiff M61/2010E v Commonwealth.  What more does the Government need? What more could the Government want? Banning asylum seekers from ever entering Australia – even very temporarily – based on one failed attempt to arrive there illegally doesn’t actually seem to advance any legitimate migration goals. It seems entirely punitive.

Indeed, this seems to be what the Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull is going for. Turnbull announced at a press conference on 30 October 2016 that the proposed law is intended to send a strong message to those attempting to reach Australia illegally – that they will be forever turned away – in an effort to thwart the operations of people smugglers, deterring their customers from considering their services. As Turnbull stated, ‘[t]hey must know that the door to Australia is closed to those who seek to come here by boat with a people smuggler. It is closed. … Those passengers will never settle in this country.’

SOURCE: Phillips, William. “Banning Refugees from Australia: Not Targeting Those Preying on the Vulnerable – Just Preying on the Vulnerable.” Oxford Human Rights Hub Blog, 14th December 2016.

Link to website

BroCAP is produced by the two librarians at the Brotherhood of St Laurence in Melbourne, Australia. If you find our service useful and would like to contribute to ‘Working for an Australia Free of Poverty’, please consider a donation using the link below.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Select list(s):

Follow BroCAP on Twitter

Click on a date to search archive

March 2017
« Feb    


Posts are for information purposes and do not constitute endorsement by the Brotherhood of St Laurence